It Happened to Jane
Re: It Happened to Jane
It Happened To Jane Movie Trivia:
Jack Lemmon wrote that he thought this was a good , funny movie that didn't do well because of its' "terrible title". He thought he and Doris Day had very good chemistry together, and he regretted that they never made another film together.
This was one of Doris Day's rare total failures at the box office, so much so that Columbia tried re-releasing it under the title Twinkle and Shine. Their second release was no more successful than the first. Later that same year Day enjoyed one of the biggest hits of her career, Pillow Talk (her first film co-starring Rock Hudson) and by the end of 1959, Day placed 4th on the Top Ten Box Office Stars.
The film's director Richard Quine , had a reputation for making perfectly charming films that somehow never caught on with movie-- goers. His other credits include Audrey Hepburn and William Holden in Paris When It Sizzles and the Jack Lemmon/Janet Leigh version of My Sister Eileen.
In the movie Teddy Rooney plays Doris Day's son Billy. Billy would later become the name of one of Doris' sons in her TV show played by Philip Brown.
Jack Lemmon wrote that he thought this was a good , funny movie that didn't do well because of its' "terrible title". He thought he and Doris Day had very good chemistry together, and he regretted that they never made another film together.
This was one of Doris Day's rare total failures at the box office, so much so that Columbia tried re-releasing it under the title Twinkle and Shine. Their second release was no more successful than the first. Later that same year Day enjoyed one of the biggest hits of her career, Pillow Talk (her first film co-starring Rock Hudson) and by the end of 1959, Day placed 4th on the Top Ten Box Office Stars.
The film's director Richard Quine , had a reputation for making perfectly charming films that somehow never caught on with movie-- goers. His other credits include Audrey Hepburn and William Holden in Paris When It Sizzles and the Jack Lemmon/Janet Leigh version of My Sister Eileen.
In the movie Teddy Rooney plays Doris Day's son Billy. Billy would later become the name of one of Doris' sons in her TV show played by Philip Brown.
Johnny
Re: It Happened to Jane
Original New York Times Review for
It Happened To Jane
by Howard Thompson
August 6- 1959
"A legal tug-of-war between a pretty lobster selling widow and a powerful railroad magnate is the subject of a bouncy good-natured little comedy called, "It Happened To Jane ", which headed a new Columbia double-bill program at neighbourhood theaters yesterday. If th kie going is a little strident and bumpy at times , the brash merriment provides more than a reasonable share of chuckles.With a good cast headed by Doris Day, Jack Lemmon, and Ernie Kovacs , the picture also provides one of the prettiest comedy backgrounds we've seen in a long time --a tint New England community, citizens included, Using a scenario by Norman Markov , the director- producer, Richard Quine- , has extracted some lively amusement from this tale of a scrappy New England woman., Miss Day and her private war with "the meanest man in the world"."deliciously played by Mr. Kovacs , as the nation watches. If their fight over a decrepit little train seems a bit sputtery and strident towards the end , no harm is done. For one thing, it moves. Mr. Quine must have told his personable cast to get in there and run. The breezy Miss Day especially at the beginning, gallops away like Paul Revere's horse, trailed by Mr. Lemmon, as a smitten home- town lawyer, Steve Forrest as a city reporter , and a winning gallery of small-town folks., Including such people as Mary Wickes and John Cecil Holm. This strictly one - gag frolic is at most disarming as a peppery close-up of small-town life -- one sequence of a town meeting is a pip. And Mr. Katkov has flavoured the proceedings nicely with some convincing dialogue and an awareness of the community's Colonial trimmings. It would be hard indeed to take offence at such a brashly friendly little picture.Nost of it is fun. And one touch, Mr. Kovacs majestically retires for the night , is hilarious. Make no mistake, everyone is certainly in there pitching -- when not running.
It Happened To Jane
by Howard Thompson
August 6- 1959
"A legal tug-of-war between a pretty lobster selling widow and a powerful railroad magnate is the subject of a bouncy good-natured little comedy called, "It Happened To Jane ", which headed a new Columbia double-bill program at neighbourhood theaters yesterday. If th kie going is a little strident and bumpy at times , the brash merriment provides more than a reasonable share of chuckles.With a good cast headed by Doris Day, Jack Lemmon, and Ernie Kovacs , the picture also provides one of the prettiest comedy backgrounds we've seen in a long time --a tint New England community, citizens included, Using a scenario by Norman Markov , the director- producer, Richard Quine- , has extracted some lively amusement from this tale of a scrappy New England woman., Miss Day and her private war with "the meanest man in the world"."deliciously played by Mr. Kovacs , as the nation watches. If their fight over a decrepit little train seems a bit sputtery and strident towards the end , no harm is done. For one thing, it moves. Mr. Quine must have told his personable cast to get in there and run. The breezy Miss Day especially at the beginning, gallops away like Paul Revere's horse, trailed by Mr. Lemmon, as a smitten home- town lawyer, Steve Forrest as a city reporter , and a winning gallery of small-town folks., Including such people as Mary Wickes and John Cecil Holm. This strictly one - gag frolic is at most disarming as a peppery close-up of small-town life -- one sequence of a town meeting is a pip. And Mr. Katkov has flavoured the proceedings nicely with some convincing dialogue and an awareness of the community's Colonial trimmings. It would be hard indeed to take offence at such a brashly friendly little picture.Nost of it is fun. And one touch, Mr. Kovacs majestically retires for the night , is hilarious. Make no mistake, everyone is certainly in there pitching -- when not running.
Johnny
Re: It Happened to Jane
In David Kaufman's book on Doris Day, there is a passage describing Jack Lemmon 's thoughts on working with Doris Day in It Happened to Jane:
"Lemmon instinctively caught the essence of Day's technique as an actress." I think she is potentially one of the greatest actresses I'll ever worked with."he said," because in every scene she is open , simple and honest that I found myself in the position of having to play up to her. Which in the parlance of actors means that she's so good that I automatically reacted to her. Doris gets a line on a scene and that's it-- boom - she comes on so forcefully that she transports fellow actors right into the scene with her".
While Day and Lemmon formed an enduring friendship in the course of making Jane, their only picture together, their mothers bonded as well. Shortly after the completion of the film , Alma and Millie Lemmon were initiated into Hollywood's Motion Picture Mothers' Association and became fast friends. Given her daughter's phenomenal success, Alma extended her vicarious thrills as a stage mother by legally changing her surname from Kapprlhogg to Day, embracing the name her daughter never liked. "She met some wonderful women through the club's. Day would say about her mother. " I always get a rundown on what everybody wore".
"Lemmon instinctively caught the essence of Day's technique as an actress." I think she is potentially one of the greatest actresses I'll ever worked with."he said," because in every scene she is open , simple and honest that I found myself in the position of having to play up to her. Which in the parlance of actors means that she's so good that I automatically reacted to her. Doris gets a line on a scene and that's it-- boom - she comes on so forcefully that she transports fellow actors right into the scene with her".
While Day and Lemmon formed an enduring friendship in the course of making Jane, their only picture together, their mothers bonded as well. Shortly after the completion of the film , Alma and Millie Lemmon were initiated into Hollywood's Motion Picture Mothers' Association and became fast friends. Given her daughter's phenomenal success, Alma extended her vicarious thrills as a stage mother by legally changing her surname from Kapprlhogg to Day, embracing the name her daughter never liked. "She met some wonderful women through the club's. Day would say about her mother. " I always get a rundown on what everybody wore".
Johnny
Re: It Happened to Jane
In Doris Day's book , Doris Day, Her Own Story, she states:
"In 1958 and 1959, I made a couple of pictures that did not do well at the box office. Tunnel of Love with Richard Widmark, and It Happened to Jane with Jack Lemmon . The former had a poor script that I did not want to do but Marty had already signed for me ; the later , which Marty also contracted for , should have done all right , it was pert and funny, but whether it was thr insipid title or something else, it just didn't make it. However, I am grateful for the film , for Jack snd I became friends and we saw each other socially over the ensuing years. Jack is a disarming and charming man , and a gut actor with a natural sense of comedy -- very challenging to work with".
"In 1958 and 1959, I made a couple of pictures that did not do well at the box office. Tunnel of Love with Richard Widmark, and It Happened to Jane with Jack Lemmon . The former had a poor script that I did not want to do but Marty had already signed for me ; the later , which Marty also contracted for , should have done all right , it was pert and funny, but whether it was thr insipid title or something else, it just didn't make it. However, I am grateful for the film , for Jack snd I became friends and we saw each other socially over the ensuing years. Jack is a disarming and charming man , and a gut actor with a natural sense of comedy -- very challenging to work with".
Johnny
Re: It Happened to Jane
In David Kaufman's book on Doris, he writes about It Happened to Jane:
"When it opened that spring, Jane fared poorly with the critics , who simply didn't know what to make of it. "Up to a point, this is a funnycomedy", wrote the review in Variety." The point is reached about three quarters of the way through When the film abruptly changes form and loses momentum...The story runs out of steam--much as the locomotive that is a central point -- because Norman Katkov's screenplay is not clearly either farce or romantic comedy. It is a farce through the major portion...Miss Day, a begging figure of outraged womanhood, doesn't lose her essential femininity in the glory of the cause. She is pugnacious but perceptibly female."
It has been my experience, that when It Happened to Jane is shown to younger members of the family, they laugh throughout the film, especially at cigar chomping Ernie Kovacs. They love the lobster Sam and they love all the action on the train. The film was not made for critics but for families who enjoy a good comedy with likable characters.
"When it opened that spring, Jane fared poorly with the critics , who simply didn't know what to make of it. "Up to a point, this is a funnycomedy", wrote the review in Variety." The point is reached about three quarters of the way through When the film abruptly changes form and loses momentum...The story runs out of steam--much as the locomotive that is a central point -- because Norman Katkov's screenplay is not clearly either farce or romantic comedy. It is a farce through the major portion...Miss Day, a begging figure of outraged womanhood, doesn't lose her essential femininity in the glory of the cause. She is pugnacious but perceptibly female."
It has been my experience, that when It Happened to Jane is shown to younger members of the family, they laugh throughout the film, especially at cigar chomping Ernie Kovacs. They love the lobster Sam and they love all the action on the train. The film was not made for critics but for families who enjoy a good comedy with likable characters.
Johnny
- howard
- Special Contributer
- Posts: 2174
- Joined: 07 Mar 2005, 12:55
- Location: north hollywood, California
- Contact:
Re: It Happened to Jane
I agree, Johnny. It's a good film - something the entire family can enjoy together. I've always felt that the "Jane" character is very much like Doris herself- the real - rather than the reel.
Like Irene Dunne done.
Re: It Happened to Jane
Thank you, Howard!
Excellent observation!
I also thought that Doris' role as Kate in Please Don't Eat the Dasies was much like the real Doris.
Excellent observation!
I also thought that Doris' role as Kate in Please Don't Eat the Dasies was much like the real Doris.
Johnny
Re: It Happened to Jane
These are two quotes from Jack Lemmon about working with Doris Day on the film, It Happened to Jane.
"Doris is a joy to work with. She was never a minute late, always good-humoured ,and always solicitous of the people around her. They were ĥer family and she cared about them , not for appearances sake, but she cared". Jack Lemmon
"She also has impeccable comedic timing which is the quality I most admire in a performer. To play with her is elevating .She makes you want to give all you've got to a scene , to rise to her level. I also feel that Doris has an enticing sexual quality that is there but subliminal".
Jack Lemmon
"Doris is a joy to work with. She was never a minute late, always good-humoured ,and always solicitous of the people around her. They were ĥer family and she cared about them , not for appearances sake, but she cared". Jack Lemmon
"She also has impeccable comedic timing which is the quality I most admire in a performer. To play with her is elevating .She makes you want to give all you've got to a scene , to rise to her level. I also feel that Doris has an enticing sexual quality that is there but subliminal".
Jack Lemmon
Johnny
Re: It Happened to Jane
Hi all
I've only seen "Jane" a couple of times over the years but was always pleasantly surprised.
However I can sort of see why the movie didn't fare that well - as others have said , the title wasn't great, the reviews were so so and the subject matter of lobsters and railroads not that rivetting - on paper anyway,
Perhaps if the movie had been made a few years later with some updating and tweaking to the sript and title, it might have been an interesting contrast to the bedroom comedies that followed "Jane" and better received.
I also think (possibly a bit controversially) that JL was not an idea leading man for DD. Don't get me wrong, I like Lemmon, but he can be a bit "frantic" and "one note" and was in "Jane" . I seem to recall him in shorts and a scout uniform or similar - not a good look -even for the time!
Having said that while its not up there with my favs, Doris saved the "day" - again!
I've only seen "Jane" a couple of times over the years but was always pleasantly surprised.
However I can sort of see why the movie didn't fare that well - as others have said , the title wasn't great, the reviews were so so and the subject matter of lobsters and railroads not that rivetting - on paper anyway,
Perhaps if the movie had been made a few years later with some updating and tweaking to the sript and title, it might have been an interesting contrast to the bedroom comedies that followed "Jane" and better received.
I also think (possibly a bit controversially) that JL was not an idea leading man for DD. Don't get me wrong, I like Lemmon, but he can be a bit "frantic" and "one note" and was in "Jane" . I seem to recall him in shorts and a scout uniform or similar - not a good look -even for the time!
Having said that while its not up there with my favs, Doris saved the "day" - again!
- howard
- Special Contributer
- Posts: 2174
- Joined: 07 Mar 2005, 12:55
- Location: north hollywood, California
- Contact:
Re: It Happened to Jane
I loved It Happened to Jane. DD was so natural, I felt like I had just spent time with Doris, and not Jane.
Like Irene Dunne done.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 13 guests


