Johnny - I'll be teaching the class again this fall in New Hampshire. You are more than welcome to drop in for a session should you travel south!!
The studio tried reissuing "It Happened to Jane" after the huge success of "Pillow Talk" and Jack's success in "Some Like it Hot" but it did no business at all. I think it would have done better with a better title although I cannot for the life of me, think of one that might work and stir interest from the public. It is a beautifully made film and Jack, who sometimes could ham a bit or allow his comic angst to overcome his character, did not do any of that in "Jane". It was an exceptional pairing of two talents and it is a shame that they were never re-teamed. I think "Jane" is destined to be one of those films that people stumble upon and end up loving.
"The Tunnel of Love" and its disappointing performance at the box-office, after the very strong showing by "Teacher's Pet" may have hurt as well as the critical barbs tossed at it. As I also mentioned, the Catholic Legion of Decency loathed it and they still had power in those days.
In reality, "Tunnel" had only been a modest Broadway hit and soon after it started playing at virtually every summer theatre, much to the disappointment of those who saw it. As a result, people were not eagerly awaiting a film version. Had it been a beloved Broadway success story, there would have been keen anticipation for the film. I don't think anyone in the co-starring role would have brought in the public. It also looked like a filmed play and audiences at the time needed a better reason to leave their television sets and go to a movie. It's lack of expansiveness was certainly detrimental.
"Jane" with its stunning location work, should have been a smash. The reviews were very good overall but I really think its the title. When I mention the film to those unaware of it, the first question is, "What happened to Jane?" When I explain the story they then want to know, "why wasn't it called something to clarify either her tackling the railroad or what a feisty character she obviously is?"
No wonder Doris never made another film at Columbia. Clearly those who marketed the film didn't mention that the title was a drawback.